BI Weekly No. 307
November 23rd- November 29th, 2006
The BI Weekly archive is available on our website: www.burmaissues.org
Inside
UN resolution will ‘destroy the peace': Burma military says
ICRC field offices' closure draws criticism
Border
UNHCR opens the legal assistance centre for refugees on Thai- Burma border
Opened letter to Thai PM to review dams on Salween, Mekong
International
UNSC update the report on Burma
UNSC call for action against child soldiers
Thai PM met Burma 's junta
* denotes BI commentary
UN resolution will ‘destroy the peace': Burma military says
The Burmese military said a UN resolution against the junta would "destroy the peace" and accused the Security Council of trying to interfere in its domestic affairs.
"The situation in Myanmar is something that does not need to be handled by the Security Council," the national police chief, Brigadier General Khin Yee told reporters.
"Only then will it become a threat to peace and security in the region, as well as to the international community as a whole," he added.
The US ambassador to the United Nations, John Bolton, said Monday he would soon introduce a draft Security Council resolution lambasting Burma 's military junta as a threat to regional peace and security, but without threatening UN sanctions.
" Myanmar warns UN resolution will 'destroy the peace'" Agence France Presse, November 29, 2006.
ICRC field offices' closure draws criticism
The Burmese government's closure of five International Committee of the Red Cross field offices, which effectively halts most of its work in the country, continues to draw criticism, the latest from the UK and US.
On Monday, the Burmese authorities ordered the ICRC to close five field offices, in Mandalay , Moulmein of Mon State, Pa-an of Karen State , Taunggyi and Kengtung of Shan State.
In a press statement released on Wednesday, British MP and Foreign Office Minister, Ian McCartney, condemned in “the strongest terms" the Burmese junta's decision.
“It is one of the few remaining independent monitors of the human rights situation in Burma and is a highly respected, neutral and independent organization,” McCartney said.
“This action by the Burmese government illustrates yet again its complete disregard for international human rights standards, and its unwillingness to engage constructively with the international community,” according to a foreign office statement.
Meanwhile, a US State Department spokesperson, Sean McCormack, called the move by Burma a “negative step” and urged the country's generals to allow the humanitarian organization to continue its work, which includes helping thousands of people in sensitive border areas.
However, the Burma government denied that it has closed down field offices of the ICRC in five areas of the country, but saying that it was just a temporary suspension.
"Burma's closure of ICRC offices draws more condemnation", Irrawaddy, November 29, 2006.
UNHCR opens the legal assistance centre for refugees on Thai- Burma border
The United Nations has opened the first of the proposed seven legal assistance centres for tens of thousands of refugees from Burma living along Thailand border with the aim to provide justice to the victims of violence that plague the border camps.
UN High Commissioner for Refugees' (UNHCR) regional representative Hasim Utkan said the centre at Ban Mae Nai Soi camp in north-western Thailand is the first of its kind "not only in Thailand , but also around the world".
All seven centres, to be funded by Italy and run by the International Rescue Committee (IRC), are scheduled to open over the next year in three camps.
Thailand does not allow refugees to move freely outside and UNHCR officials are not allowed in the camps overnight, when incidents of violent crimes, especially rapes and acts of domestic violence, occur.
A report from the UN refugee agency indicated that more than 350 serious crimes were reported across the nine camps between 2003 and 2006, with rape and domestic violence the most common and children often the victims.
A survey conducted in September by the IRC found that 63 per cent of residents in three of the camps had serious concerns about their safety. They had little confidence in the Thai justice system. Kirsten Young, UNHCR regional assistant representative for protection, said the centres will act as the agency's "eyes and ears in the camps". They will also help to channel cases to the Thai justice system and also work on building the
capacity of the "refugee traditional justice mechanisms to handle cases in a manner consistent with basic human rights principles".
The centres are designed to act as an information hub on human rights, protection and the legal process, and also offer individual counseling for camp residents who have suffered human rights violations or been implicated in crimes.
"UN opens legal assistance centre for Myanmar refugees", The Press Trust of India, November 25, 2006.
Opened letter to Thai PM to review dams on Salween, Mekong
About half of the 400 participants at a seminar, "Mekong-Salween: People, Water, and the Golden Land of Southeast Asia" organized by the Social Sciences and Humanities
Foundation in Chiang Mai, signed an open letter urging Prime Minister Surayud Chulanont to review government policies that will directly affect more than 100 million people in six countries along the Mekong and Salween rivers.
"We, who signed the letter, demand that your government review the policies or projects that would lead to dam constructions on Mekong and Salween rivers as well as investments in big projects that would disturb the ecosystem and way of life of the people," the letter said.
The letter also urged the interim prime minister to focus not only on a free-trade economy but also issues of human security, natural resources, and the lifestyles of the river communities.
The Thai government last year signed a memorandum of understanding with the Burmese military junta to study the possibility of building dams in the Salween and Tenasserim river basins.
The six planned projects would seriously affect the way of life of large numbers in Burma 's ethnic areas, and may have already led to forced relocation in Shan and Karen states.
Laos has just revealed plans for 23 dams on the Mekong by 2020, to generate electricity for Thailand and Vietnam
"Concern over dams on Salween, Mekong" The Nation ( Thailand ), November 24, 2006.
UNSC update the report on Burma
The United Nations Security Council is preparing to take the next step in addressing the Burma question. Yet the case remains that there is no consensus, and many questions abound, regarding exactly what future actions will be undertaken.
On November 22, the United Nations Security Council issued an Update Report pertaining to potential forthcoming steps to be taken against the Burmese government.
The updated report, however, in addition to listing options available for Security Council measures points to reasons why this is sure to remain a highly divisive issue. Further, the report, in its simplified analysis, serves to gloss over confrontational aspects of the current UN approach.
Following an expected briefing by Gambari before the end of the month, the 15 members of the Security Council will then have four options available to them: no action; an informal response in conjunction with an expansion of a US plan; discussion of US proposals at an expert level, or; the issuance of a presidential statement.
Issues raised with the government during the latest visit are given as a continued call for an inclusive democratic process as well as the release of Aung San Suu Kyi from house arrest, in conjunction with calls for improved working relations with the International Labour Organization and other humanitarian agencies. Gambari also urged the government to cease its military offensives in Karen State .
The report lists achievements of the visit as including meetings with Aung San Suu Kyi and ethnic groups involved in the National Convention. This positive spin contrasts with many opinions of ethnic and political groups regarding the efficacy of Gambari's itinerary. This includes concerns voiced by the NLD and other organizations not invited or not willing to be party to the National Convention.
“Security Council to continue Burma debate” Mizzima News, November 24, 2006.
UNSC call for action against child soldiers
The UN Security Council has repeated its call for action against the recruitment of child soldiers in countries considered the worst offenders, including Burma .
During a special day-long session to consider a UN report on progress to fight the problem, the council heard of “reliable reports” that the Tatmadaw (Burma Army) continues to recruit child soldiers. The junta was also accused of failing to cooperate fully with the UN in Burma in attempts to eradicate the problem, charges denied by the government.
Speaking to the council, Burmese government representative Kyaw Tint Swe said the report contained “unfounded allegations,” and that appropriate measures had been put into place to eradicate the problem, including discharging minors from the military.
Radhika Coomaraswamy, the special representative of the UN secretary-general for children and armed conflict, said that commitments to demobilize troops in Burma , along with the Ivory Coast , Burundi and Uganda , “would result in concrete action.” However, her report to the council said it was currently impossible to verify Burmese government efforts to eradicate the problem.
The Tatmadaw has long been accused of forcibly recruiting children to its 400,000-strong armed forces. In 2004, the London-based Coalition to Stop the Use of Child Soldiers reported that the junta had in some cases kidnapped children as young as 11, forcing them to serve in the military. At the time, it estimated that up to 20 percent of Tatmadaw and ethnic insurgency forces were under 18—the current legal age of conscription—which would have put the total number of child soldiers in Burma at nearly 90,000, the highest of any country in the world.
"UN repeats call for action on child soldiers" Irrawaddy , November 29, 2006.
Thai PM met Burma 's junta
Thailand 's army-installed premier on Thursday pressed Burma 's junta for democratic reform in a one-day visit. Thai PM, General Surayud, met Senior General Than Shwe at the new capital, Naypyidaw, earlier in the day and then, had a separate one-hour meeting with Prime Minister Soe Win. Largely in the hope of avoiding that comparison, Surayud Chulanont made Burma the last stop in his series of visits around Southeast Asia since the military appointed him after the coup.
"I asked Mr Than Shwe to consider democratic reform in Myanmar , which is a member of ASEAN," Surayud told reporters after returning to Bangkok .
Burma 's democratic reform would be further discussed at the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) summit next month in the Philippines .
Surayud said he also had "an informal talk" with Soe Win about the detained democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi, but declined to give further details.
Surayud's government, have insisted they want to end the business dealings with Burma that ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra fostered.
However, they will find that difficult to do. Thailand last year was by far the largest foreign investor in Burma , due to a six billion dollar dam the kingdom is building across the border to generate electricity for its own use. They also pipes about one billion cubic feet of gas each day from Burma 's offshore reserves in the southeast, in the Andaman Sea .
Surayud shows no sign of backing away from these deals. However, Thai Energy Minister Piyasvasti Amranand accompanied Surayud on the trip, and Thai media reported that Thailand hoped to discuss expanding energy deals.
"Thai PM's Myanmar visit invites uncomfortable comparisons" Agence France Presse, November 23, 2006
|